Home Shop Cart Account

Shop

All Nut Butters

All Nut Butters

Filter products by category, price, and more

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 Nerdy Nuts. All rights reserved.

...

NEW

Hot Cocoa Peanut Butter

$13.99

NEW

Caramel Stix Peanut Butter Treat

$13.99

NEW

Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter

$7.99

-65%NEW

White Chocolate Peanut Butter

$6.99

$2.45

NEW

Peanut Butter Dreams

$13.99

NEW

Fluffernutter Peanut Butter

$13.99

NEW

Cinnamon Roll Peanut Butter

$10.99

NEW

Salty Turtle Peanut Butter

$13.99

-65%NEW

Fruity Nibbles Peanut Butter

$13.99

$4.90

-65%NEW

Bark Butter (Pup Treat)

$10.99

$3.85

NEW

German Chocolate Cake Peanut Butter

$13.99

NEW

Cinnamon Crunch Peanut Butter Treat

$13.99